Q. Should I get silicone or saline implants? Is there a price difference?
A. We believe that saline breast implants are safer than silicone gel implants.
All breast implants have risks. The most common is when the breast gets hard and painful, known as capsular contracture. Many women with implants have that problem after a few years, but it appears to be more common with silicone gel breast implants than saline implants.
Implant surgery usually costs between $5,000-8,000, including the implants and one follow-up visit. Silicone gel breast implants cost about $1,000 more than saline implants.
However, there are a lot of extra expenses that you need to be aware of.
For example, saline implants and silicone implants both have a high complication rate, and almost half the women will need additional surgery to fix implant problems within 3-4 years. Some problems are cosmetic (if the breasts look phony) and some problems are more serious (such as infections, allergic reactions, or auto-immune reactions). That additional surgery often costs $5,000 or more. That is why we suggest that women considering breast implants make sure they have at least $5,000 in their savings that they will save and not spend until they need it for their next implant surgery.
All breast implants will eventually break, but when saline implants break it is obvious (they deflate quickly) and when silicone gel breast implants break, there are often no symptoms at first. Having no symptoms might seem like an advantage, but it is really a disadvantage because silicone can leak out of the tear in the implant, and get to parts of the body where surgeons can’t remove it. Leaking silicone can cause pain and allergic or auto-immune reactions. When it is removed, the breast may be deformed.
Because of concerns about leaking silicone, the FDA warns that women with silicone gel breast implants need to get an MRI to check for leakage after 3 years, and then every other year after that. Unfortunately, breast MRIs cost about $2,000 each, sometimes more. That may seem very expensive, but it is the only accurate way to know if your implants are broken or leaking. If they are leaking, it is important to have them removed immediately.
Given the expense and the risks, why would any woman get silicone gel breast implants? There is one advantage: they feel more like a real breast. Saline implants may not feel as warm as the rest of the body in cold weather. (A figure skater told us they were painfully cold!) And, women with saline implants sometimes say that they make swooshing water noises. Most plastic surgeons prefer silicone gel implants because they tend to look and feel more natural. However, many women tell us that does not make up for the added risks and added costs.
But, it is important to know that all breast implants – saline or silicone – can cause serious health problems. They can even cause a type of cancer of the immune system, known as anaplastic large cell lymphoma (ALCL).
The bottom line: all breast implants will break, all breast implants are likely to cause complications that require additional surgery, and some women will have a bad reaction within a few weeks or months of getting their breast implants. Some complications are very serious. But some breast implants are safer than others, and since all silicone gel breast implants are more likely to leak as they get older, we believe that saline implants are safer.
Photos of what happens when removing silicone
deforms the breast. Click for larger view.
The comments and statements of the National Center for Health Research are believed and intended to be accurate, and where applicable, based on scientific literature. NCHR’s statements do not constitute medical diagnoses, medical advice, plans of treatment, or legal opinion, and we are not responsible for the use or application of this information. All medical information should be reviewed with your health care practitioner.
We hope that the information we’ve provided is helpful. In order to maintain this free service, we invite your tax-deductible contributions to NCHR (see http://www.center4research.org/contribute.html)